April 21, 1999
Jim Broyles
Director of Laboratories
Department of Geosciences
State University of New York
Stony Brook
Dear Jim:
I am left with no choice but to bring to your attention serious problems with the performance of the machine shop employees. As you know, the machine shop makes parts for high-pressure experiments carried out in the Stony Brook High Pressure Lab, which is the core research facility of the Mineral Physics Institute at Stony Brook. It is essential that we have some limited supply of these parts to maintain an uninterrupted operation of this facility. Unfortunately, during the last six months, I had to make an extraordinary effort to assure that there were no interruptions in the research. This is because the machine shop has become extremely uncooperative in maintaining this limited supply of parts, and we have been constantly running out of one part or another. Even if we receive the parts, the orders are often incomplete and the parts substandard. Despite my repeated, and increasingly stern, requests for correction, the situation has not changed, and we are now very close to experiencing serious disruptions in our research.
This situation is by no means caused by some unforeseen extra workload. Quite contrary, among the high-pressure equipment in the lab, only the split-sphere anvil apparatus is more or less in full use. The Kennedy press is used very rarely, and the girdle is not used at all. In addition, most experiments on the split-sphere anvil apparatus are currently 2-day experiments, while, in the past, 1-day experiments were much more common. Thus, the current need for the assembly parts is, perhaps, only 30 % of the need during the full operation of the lab. Needless to say, for many years, the lab was very close to full use without any problems remotely similar to the current problems with the assembly parts, despite having the same number of machinists.
I suspect that the current problems with the performance are mainly caused by excessive absenteeism among the employees. We have been quite tolerant in the past about the occasional unjustified absences, as long as the performance did not suffer. This is no longer the case. I find too often only one machinist present in the shop, who, without the supervision, is just as likely to work as not. While all machinists apparently take extra days off, the person most responsible is the foreman, who is absent the most of all and thus has no moral authority to impose the discipline on his subordinates.
Therefore, I must request, as the minimum step toward correcting the current situation, a more stringent supervision of the attendance of the machine shop employees, for example, by introducing time punching. The next step may include replacing the foreman, who is extremely unpopular among the machinists, and who is responsible for the operation of the machine shop. We should also seriously consider the benefits of the central machine shop, where maintaining higher professional standards is more likely, while reducing the possibility of favoritism, which is also a part of the current problems.
I hope you take the necessary steps to assure adequate improvements in the current unacceptable performance of the machine shop employees.
Sincerely,
Tibor Gasparik
Associate Professor for Research and
Manager of the High Pressure Laboratory
Cc: Professor Robert C. Liebermann, Chairman, Department of Geosciences
Professor Donald J. Weidner, Director, Center for High Pressure Research